Monday, September 5, 2011

High Court Erodes 4th Amendment

HIGH COURT ERODES 4TH AMENDMENT IN SEARCH AND SEIZURE CASE

Last month, an 8-1 majority of the United States Supreme Court ruled in favor of law enforcement in a case involving the exigent circumstances rule which is an exception to the 4th Amendment’s search warrant requirement.

The case, Kentucky v. King, arose when police were chasing a drug trafficker into an apartment building but did not know into which of two apartment units the suspects entered.  They approached the unit where they said they smelled marijuana.  After knocking and announcing their presence, the officers said they heard noises inside “as if things were moving around.”  Thinking that evidence was being destroyed, they kicked in the door and found illegal drugs.

The police arrested Hollis King, who subsequently sought to have the drug evidence suppressed.  The Kentucky Supreme Court ultimately held that the exigent circumstances (the possible destruction of evidence) could not justify the warrantless search.

In reversing the state high court, Justice Alito wrote, “A rule that precludes the police from making a warrantless entry to prevent the destruction of evidence whenever their conduct causes the exigency would unreasonably shrink the reach of this well established exception to the warrant requirement.”  Where the police, as in this case, did not create the exigency “by engaging or threatening to engage in conduct that violates the 4th Amendment, warrantless entry to prevent the destruction of evidence is reasonable and thus allowed,” he said.

Justice Ginsburg authored the lone dissent.  As the Kentucky Supreme Court found, she said that nothing made it impractical for police to post officers on the premises while they went to get a warrant to enter the apartment.  “The urgency must exist, I would rule, when the police come on the scene, not subsequent to their arrival, prompted by their own conduct,”she wrote.  “How secure do our homes remain if police, armed with no warrant, can pound on doors at will and, on hearing sounds indicative of things moving around, forcibly enter and search for evidence of unlawful activity?”

I must say that in this rare circumstance, I fully agree with Justice Ginsburg.  While she does not generally adhere to a judicial philosophy that appreciates the original meaning of the Constitution, she seems to make exceptions on 4th Amendment cases.

No offense to my law enforcement friends, but my concern is that this case will make it easier for an officer to enter a home without the hassle of getting a search warrant.  This case described the shuffling noises that were heard inside to justify a warrantless search.  Next time it may be a banging noise, unusual music, or some other strange thing that can be heard from outside the house.  Where do we stop?  The slippery slope of 4th Amendment warrant exceptions has steepened over time and it is difficult to draw the line in these type of cases.

The 4th Amendment warrant requirement is one of the aspects of American jurisprudence that makes the citizenry the safest group of people in history.  The concept was taken from England where the king and his minions could ransack the homes and imprison his subjects with impunity.

By strictly applying this constitutional protection, we are secure in our homes, bodies, and personal possessions.  The courts must take an originalist approach in applying the 4th Amendment warrant requirement to cases where a search warrant was not secured.

Unfortunately, in order to protect the people, good and bad, you must sometimes allow a criminal to go free.  This is one of the truest realities of life. 

Implied Consent in Georgia

IMPLIED CONSENT IN GEORGIA

I have found that one of the key concepts of DUI procedure in Georgia is often misunderstood by motorists in our community.  This concept is known as “implied consent”. 

Implied consent is an idea that was created many years ago after cars and trucks became part of everyday life and the highways of our state became used with regularity.  The idea, which is outlined in the Georgia Code, encompasses the belief that because a motorist decides to use roads and other terrain to drive, that person has impliedly consented to submit to chemical testing if a law enforcement officer has a legitimate belief that the driver is impaired by consuming alcohol or drugs. 

When a police officer pulls a driver over and believes that the driver is impaired, he or she will frequently want for the driver to take a chemical test of their breath, blood, or urine.  Under most circumstances, the officer must read the implied consent warning.  The implied consent warning is typically read from a small card kept in the officer’s pocket.  The implied consent warning for motorists over 21 years of age informs suspects that (1) the officer is requesting a chemical test, (2) failure to submit to the test or blowing over 0.08 will result in a suspension of the driver’s license for 1 year, and (3) after taking the test, an independent test can be obtained. 

At this point, the motorist has an important choice to make.  A common misconception is that a driver should always refuse the test.  However, if the motorist refuses to take the state’s administered test, then the officer can file paperwork with the state whereby the motorist’s driver’s license will be subject to suspension.  This could put a defendant who may have just consumed 1 or 2 beers in an unfavorable position. 

However, if the motorist takes the state’s administered test, then the results of that test may be admissible in a future criminal prosecution for DUI.  A person who is well over the legal limit would have to deal with the consequences of a possible license suspension and the prospect of defending a case where a high blood alcohol content is involved.

Another important aspect of the implied consent law in Georgia focuses on the independent test.  I have had numerous clients who decided to take the state’s administered test and did not ask to have an independent test administered because they did not know that they had a right to get one. This request always needs to be made if the driver chooses to take the state’s test because the motorist has a right to have an independent test performed. 

The independent test is usually performed at a local hospital or other medical facility that has the means to legally obtain the driver’s blood or urine.  If the officer impedes the facilitation of an independent test or fails to reasonably accommodate the driver in obtaining an independent test, then the state’s administered test will be excluded from evidence at trial. 

The bottom line is that the implied consent law in Georgia is designed to strongly encourage motorists who are suspected of driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs to take a chemical sobriety test administered by law enforcement.  While there are differing opinions about the value of this law, it is probably a good idea overall.  The implied consent law assists law enforcement officers in keeping impaired drivers off the road. 

In order to avoid these consequences altogether, it would be a good idea to simply refuse to drive if you have had a sip of anything to drink.  Trying to gauge when you are “ok to drive” after you have been drinking is not a very effective way to avoid DUI related consequences.  Besides, having any amount of alcohol in your system while being pulled over by a law enforcement officer is never a pleasant experience. 

History of Voir Dire

THE HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE OF JURY SELECTION

I have written a couple of columns in the past about some of the procedures associated with jury selection (voir dire) and the importance of jury service.  However, I have found that one of most interesting aspects of the voir dire process is found in the early historical record of our country. 

The word “voir dire” is a Latin term that means “speak the truth”.  In Georgia, juries are actually de-selected rather than selected by each side striking potential jurors from a case.  Each side usually has a good idea which jurors need to be removed from a case based on the answers that the jurors give during the voir dire process.  Today, voir dire is as much a fundamental American tradition as the right for a defendant to be presumed innocent in a criminal case until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.  Without voir dire, the prosecution and defense would not be in a position to assist the court in developing the best jury for a particular case.  Thus, you could not actually have a trial by jury under such circumstances. 

Well, how did voir dire become such a fundamental American tradition?  As the United States was beginning to consider independence, England enacted the Massachusetts Jury Selection Law of 1760, which prohibited the questioning of jurors once the sheriff had chosen them for duty.  The inability of both parties to explore the views of potential jurors angered the citizenry and actually served as one of many justifications for independence. 

When our Founders drafted and signed the Declaration of Independence, one of the main justifications for breaking away from England was King George III’s depriving the colonists the right to be tried by a jury.  This continued denial of such a fundamental right based on natural law helped to spark the Revolution.

By the time the United States of America had come into being, voir dire had become a foundation of American jurisprudence.  One of the first legal cases addressing the importance of voir dire and cementing the right of parties to question juries about their preconceptions about a case was the treason prosecution of Aaron Burr.  In United States v. Burr (1807), Chief Justice John Marshall, while sitting as the trial judge, recognized that an impartial jury was required by the common law and secured by the Constitution.  This case put the world on notice that the United States was serious about protecting constitutional rights. 

Since the early 1800's, The United States Supreme Court has consistently recognized the importance of the voir dire process.  Case after case has held that the Constitution, particularly the 6th Amendment, recognizes the right to a trial by jury.  The prevailing view in legal circles today is that voir dire is the key tool for protecting an individual’s right to an impartial jury. 

Thomas Jefferson, perhaps the most courageous of our Founding Fathers, was quoted as saying “I consider trial by jury as the only anchor ever yet imagined by man, by which a government can be held to the principles of its constitution.”  It seems that Jefferson understood that holding government to its foundational, enumerated, and very limited principles is an ongoing process. I hope that a larger percentage of Americans will begin to understand why Thomas Jefferson felt this way. 

The Great Southern Outdoors

The Great Southern Outdoors

As I write this column, my family, friends and I are relaxing at Lake Wedowee in Randolph Co., Alabama. This Memorial Day weekend is special for many reasons. The biggest reason is that it gives us the opportunity to think about, pray about, and show gratitude for our troops both present and past. This weekend also reminds me that as southern Americans, we have a massive wealth of natural resources to enjoy with our loved ones.

This weekend, I am able to take my boys on one of the cleanest lakes in the southeast. Here, we experience the natural lake habitat which includes the waterfowl flying over at dawn, the fish in the lakes and streams, osprey nests, and the other fauna and flora which are native to this region..

The lake experience also makes me look forward to taking my son, Jake, down to  Meriwether County this fall. There is a peace which exists in the fall woods in Georgia that cannot be duplicated anywhere else. In the woods, you will see deer, turkey, and many other of God's creatures. This is all experienced while actually being in that natural environment as opposed to viewing wildlife and nature from a moving automobile.

In the mornings, the owls wake the woods with their hoots while the coyotes serenade throughout the night. Throughout the day, I can hunt with my son and teach him about the behavior and characteristics of the game animals that we pursue.  It is truly a blessing to be able to take your children into such natural environments.

I believe that God created us to commune with nature on a regular basis. In today's world, that may be harder to believe than in days past. Offices, automobiles, cell phones, and other modern inventions have taken us away from our natural environment. Many people would prefer to spend time indoors where the thermometer can be adjusted to the preferred temperature.

I am proud that Jake seems to have inherited my strong desire to be outdoors.  Shea and I can hardly keep him in the house when we are at home.  His yearning for adventure and interest in learning about the trees, animals, and environment has been a strong source of gratitude for me.

Fortunately, we live in a region of the country that not only provides enormous natural resources, but opportunity for us to enjoy it. Because of private property rights, we can own and use land in a manner that we see fit. Also, the states of Georgia and Alabama as well as the federal government have purchased property for public use as Wildlife Management Areas, state and national parks, and lake reservoirs.

This unique mixture of public/private land use allows Americans to experience the outdoors to the fullest extent possible.  In the United States, you can be rich, poor, or somewhere in between and still be able to live a lifestyle that includes the outdoors.  Hunting, fishing, camping, hiking, cycling, swimming, rock climbing and shooting sports are all freely available in this country.  I cannot say this for most countries on Earth.

We enjoy these freedoms because American soldiers and patriotic citizens have and continue to protect our Constitution.  I encourage all of my readers to get outdoors a little more this year.  When you do, also think about those Americans who have sacrificed to make your outdoor experience possible.

The Goodness of the American Lawyer

THE GOODNESS OF THE AMERICAN LAWYER

After practicing criminal law for a number of years, I have heard my share of lawyer jokes.  I must say that most lawyer jokes are quite funny because they are based on true events that take place in courtrooms.  In fact, I have probably seen things take place in court that are funnier than any joke that you could come up with.

Despite the good and bad natured jokes about lawyers and the sometimes negative press that we endure, I believe that my fellow attorneys are generally very good people.  Here are some of my observations about lawyers in the west Georgia area that support this conclusion:

1.    COMMUNITY SERVICE - I have noticed that lawyers in our community are some of the most giving people when it comes to time and money.  Whether it be representing someone on a pro bono basis or giving money to organizations like local churches and soup kitchens, lawyers are always there for support.

    For example, the West Georgia Trial Lawyer’s Association recently held our 2nd Annual C.A.R.E.S. Bicycle Helmet Giveaway at Mayfest in Carrollton.  We, along with the Carrollton FOP and the Carrollton Police Explorers gave out almost 300 bicycle helmets to children in our community to promote bike safety and injury prevention.

2.    FRIENDSHIP AND FELLOWSHIP - Some of my best friends in this world are other attorneys.  Personally, I have developed deep bonds with many of my colleagues through my practice, the storms of trials, and through our weekly Pathfinders Bible study which consists of lawyers and non-lawyers.  I can personally attest that some of the most loyal, trusted people I have come to know in my community are lawyers.

3.    JUSTICE SYSTEM - If I counted the number of complaints that I have heard over the years about the justice system, I would still be counting next month.  Nevertheless, as I have said many times in prior columns, we have the best system.  The attorney participants in that system significantly assist in making it work.

    Our judges must make the tough day to day decisions that have huge impacts on the lives of citizens.  The defense attorneys and prosecutors must put forward their respective positions of protecting the rights of the accused and of the victims of crimes.  The personal injury lawyers must protect the rights of the injured while the divorce attorneys are taking on the most devastating of circumstances when families are destroyed.

    This is all done in a relatively orderly manner and governed by the rule of law.  While many litigants are not happy with the outcome of their cases, the criminal and civil justice system provides for an alternative to raw human justice.  Raw justice would have such attributes as vigilante justice and violent retribution in criminal cases, the forceful taking of another’s property in civil disputes, and the violent disintegration of the family unit in divorce matters.  In a word, it would be chaos.

I am proud to be a member of my profession and am proud of my local colleagues as well.  We are a diverse group with different practice areas, and different belief systems.  But, I am happy that when I receive emails from people in the community with legal problems, I can, without hesitation, point them in the direction of a good local attorney who I can trust.

Georgia's New Immigration Law

GEORGIA’ NEW IMMIGRATION LAW


On May 13, 2011, Gov. Nathan Deal signed into law the Illegal Immigration Reform and Enforcement Act of 2011.  This new law, which is somewhat similar to the much publicized law in Arizona, is the most sweeping change in immigration policy in the history of this state.

While legal challenges are expected and might delay implementation, it is scheduled to take effect on July 1, 2011.

The law imposes new criminal penalties on anyone employing illegal immigrants. It also imposes new criminal penalties on anyone who uses fraudulent identification in order to get a job and on those who transport or “harbor” illegal immigrants. The law also gives law enforcement officers in the state the power to enforce federal immigration laws in certain circumstances and requires most private employers to use a federal verification system known as E-Verify to screen those who have been hired for jobs.

The new immigration law:

    1.    Creates a new criminal offense of aggravated identity fraud for anyone willfully using fraudulent documents to get a job. A person under 21 would be punished by 1-3 years in prison and/or a fine up to $5,000. Those 21 and up would face minimally 1-10 years in jail and/or a fine up to $100,000.
  
  2.    Empowers any peace officer with probable cause to believe a person has committed a criminal offense, including a traffic offense, to investigate their immigration status if they cannot produce valid identification and detain them if they are found to be in the country illegally.
 
3.    States that a person’s race, color or country of origin is not to be a determinant in investigating their immigration status.

 4.    States that a person who contacts the police to report a crime, as a witness to a crime or victim of a crime will not have their status investigated.
  
  5.    Requires that when anyone is held in county or municipal jail for any reason, an effort is made to verify that they are in the country legally and if they are not in the country legally, immigration authorities will be notified and they will be subject to detention.
  
  6.    Creates a new criminal offense: transporting or moving an illegal alien. Creates a new criminal offense: knowingly and intentionally inducing an illegal alien to enter Georgia. Penalties range from less than 1 year in jail and/or a fine to 1-5 years in jail and/or a fine.
        Creates a new criminal offense: concealing or harboring an illegal alien. Harboring is defined to mean anything that substantially helps an illegal alien to remain in the United States. Exceptions are: a person helping infants or children, a crime victim, in a medical emergency, a person offering privately funded social services, or attorney-client representation. Penalties mirror those for transporting an illegal alien.

    6.    Requires any private employer with more than 10 employees to use the federal E-Verify program to determine that any newly hired employee is in the country legally. This will be effective on Jan. 1, 2012 for employers with 500 or more employees, July 2012 for employers of 100 up to 499 employees and July 1, 2013 for employers of more than 10 but fewer than 100 employees. In order to receive a business license or renew a license, businesses will have to show they are registered with E-Verify. Violation of this will be a criminal offense.

Although this law will be tested by legal challenges, there is a substantial likelihood that it will pass constitutional muster.  Many of the problems with the Arizona law were preemptively addressed with this legislation.  Like it or not, the Illegal Immigration Reform and Enforcement Act of 2011 will become part of the legal reality in Georgia.

A Fair Trial and a Free Press

A FAIR TRIAL AND FREE PRESS

I recently had the opportunity to pen a column outlining the accused’s right to have a public trial.  While this is a bedrock principle of American criminal procedure, what about the right of the press to be present and report on the happenings of a trial?

In Richmond Newspapers Inc. v.Virginia, the United States Supreme Court in 1980 said that the press and the public have a federal constitutional right to be able to attend criminal trials unless the trial judge makes a finding which supports closure.  There is a presumption in favor of open trials even in cases where the defense and the prosecution agree that a non-public trial may be conducted.  Should either party, or the court itself, feel that there is a good reason to close any part of the trial to the public, the trial court has an independent duty to consider “all reasonable alternatives” that could ensure a fair and open trial even if neither party suggests an alternative to closure.

In 1982, the Supreme Court went on to give some of its reasons why the press should be able to report on criminal trials.  In reversing a mandatory closure order in Massachusetts, the Court held that such orders violate the First Amendment and pointed out that (1) criminal trials have historically been open to the press and general public, and that (2) public scrutiny of a criminal trial enhances the quality and safeguards of a fact-finding process, gives the appearance of fairness, and heightens public respect for the judicial process.

Even though the prosecution or defense may want for a portion or all of a trial to be closed from press coverage, the moving party carries a rather large burden to get this done.  The party seeking to close a hearing must (1) advance an overriding interest that it is likely to be prejudiced; (2) the court must ensure that the closure be no broader than necessary to protect that interest; (3) the court must always consider reasonable alternatives to closure; and (4) the court must make adequate findings on the record to support its decision.  

As with every rule of law, there are reasonable exceptions which need to be applied under some circumstances.  O.C.G.A 17-8-53 and 17-8-54 authorize the closure of the courtroom to the public where the subject matter of the proceeding involves evidence which relates to the “improper acts of the sexes and tends to debauch the morals of the young” or in a case where a child under the age of 16 who is testifying in a criminal case involving a sexual offense.  However, the trial court must still conduct an inquiry and exercise careful discretion when limiting press coverage even in these circumstances.

In reality, very few criminal trials are closed to press coverage.  All you have to do is turn on the television, plug into the internet, or pick up the local newspaper to see vast coverage of trials across the country.  Even though I have some cases where the allegations are such that I would prefer to have the least amount of coverage possible, I firmly believe that open press coverage in criminal trials is a good thing and 100% American.  By allowing the press to report on trials, the federal and state courts have clearly and almost unanimously sided with the Constitution, particularly with the First Amendment.  This cannot be said of most issues coming before the courts.
The other aspect of free press coverage of trials that I am proud of is that this freedom differentiates America from many other countries and cultures.  At a time when powerful forces both domestic and international seek to undermine and mock the idea of American prominence in the world, shining the light on our God-given constitutional law is all the more important.